Pine Island Gas Prices - Find the Lowest Gas Prices in Pine Island, NY

Search for the lowest gasoline prices in Pine Island, NY. Find local Pine Island gas prices and Pine Island gas stations with the best prices to fill up at the pump today

National and New York Gas Price Averages

National Avg.	NY Reg. Avg.	NY Plus Avg.	NY Prem. Avg.	NY Diesel Avg.
$3.160 12/26/2025	$3.165 12/26/2025	$3.681 12/26/2025	$4.060 12/26/2025	$3.912 12/26/2025

Today's lowest gas prices in New York and around Pine Island

Station	Regular	Plus	Premium	Diesel
Mike's Trading Post 2342 Printup Rd, Sanborn, NY	$2.59 12/26/2025	12/26/2025	$3.88 12/26/2025	$3.25 12/26/2025
Ron's Smoke Shop 5001 NY-417, Allegany, NY	$2.61 12/26/2025	$2.91 12/26/2025	12/26/2025	12/26/2025

Find all gas prices in and around Pine Island, NY.

Add an Event

Local Events

Skylands Stadium Christmas Light Show and Village

Friday, Dec 26, 2025 at 4:45pm

Augusta, NJ

More info »

Skylands Stadium Christmas Light Show and Village

Saturday, Dec 27, 2025 at 4:45pm

Augusta, NJ

More info »

Skylands Stadium Christmas Light Show and Village

Sunday, Dec 28, 2025 at 4:45pm

Augusta, NJ

More info »

K-Pop Demon Hunters Dance Party and Sing-A-Long Experience!

Saturday, Jan 3, 2026 at 10:00am

Atlantic City, NJ

More info »

K-Pop Demon Hunters Dance Party and Sing-A-Long Experience!

Saturday, Jan 3, 2026 at 12:00pm

Atlantic City, NJ

More info »

K-Pop Demon Hunters Dance Party and Sing-A-Long Experience!

Saturday, Jan 3, 2026 at 2:30pm

Atlantic City, NJ

More info »

K-Pop Demon Hunters Dance Party and Sing-A-Long Experience!

Saturday, Jan 3, 2026 at 5:00pm

Atlantic City, NJ

More info »

Tom Swoope

Sunday, Jan 4, 2026 at 7:30pm

Montgomery, NY

More info »

Milford Theater Membership

Wednesday, Jan 14, 2026 at 12:00pm

Milford, PA

More info »

Lil Mo Mozzarella

Friday, Jan 16, 2026 at 7:00pm

Atlantic City, NJ

More info »

See All Events

In and Around Pine Island, NY

Apple Picking Corn Mazes Pumpkin Picking Halloween Events Restaurants Movie Times Car Deals and Guide Real Estate Jobs Classifieds Gas Prices Museums Coffee Spots Parks

Nr	Query	Num. rows	Took (ms)
1	db.towns.find( {"sef_url":"central-ak"}, [] ).sort( [] ).limit( 1 ).skip( 0 )	1	4
2	db.sites.find( {"hostname":{"$in":["americantowns.com","localword"]}}, [] ).sort( [] ).limit( 1 ).skip( 0 )	1	1
3	db.towns.find( {"sef_url":"pine-island-ny"}, [] ).sort( [] ).limit( 1 ).skip( 0 )	1	1
4	db.pages.find( {"type":"town","slug":{"$in":["gas-prices"]},"site.hostname":"americantowns.com"}, [] ).sort( [] ).limit( 1 ).skip( 0 )	1	1
5	db.modules.find( {"name":{"$in":["Header Menu Main","header script","footer menu","footer script"]}}, [] ).sort( [] ).limit( 0 ).skip( 0 )	4	1
6	db.events_cache.find( {"_id":"f6a7d4985b0fff9361bdd89592604b50"}, [] ).sort( [] ).limit( 1 ).skip( 0 )	0	1
7	db.events_radius_cache.find( {"_id":"44e23d4957b2316e0e77c5706e188e4b"}, [] ).sort( [] ).limit( 1 ).skip( 0 )	1	1
8	db.events.find( {"start":{"$gte":"MongoDate(0.00000000 1766728800)"},"geo":{"$geoWithin":{"$center":[[-74.45939636230469,41.29790115356445],0.36231884057971014]}}}, ["location_string","event_id","partner_id","address","sef_tail","tags","title","start","end","date_string","time_string","image_url","group_id","group_name","group_sef_tail","venue_name"] ).sort( {"start":1} ).limit( 11 ).skip( 0 )	11	317
9	db.events_cache.count( {"_id":"f6a7d4985b0fff9361bdd89592604b50"} )	0	1
10	db.events_cache.count( {"_id":"f6a7d4985b0fff9361bdd89592604b50"} )	0	1
11	db.events_cache.insert( {"_id":"f6a7d4985b0fff9361bdd89592604b50","town_sef_url":"pine-island-ny","data_key":["68fab59b0118f5e48e0f6b15","68fab59b0118f5e48e0f6b16","68fab59b0118f5e48e0f6b17","694df18ede4ae56f5aabd7b4","693b7c9fde4ae56f5a5ab4bb","693b7c9fde4ae56f5a5ab4c5","693e1f91de4ae56f5aa92d14","69351d54de4ae56f5ae250e9","687e27a0fb5e4bed1f727348","68fc34a0c3af739f252269f1"],"sort_order":{"start":1},"params":"{\"show\":10,\"title\":\"Local Events\",\"images\":false,\"empty-message\":\"no\",\"keyword\":\"\",\"radius\":25,\"limit\":15,\"page\":1,\"sef\":\"\",\"tags\":\"\",\"tags_logical\":\"\",\"terms\":\"\",\"show_limit\":3,\"sort\":\"\",\"days\":\"\",\"max-days\":365,\"max-miles\":45,\"message\":\"[message to follow]\",\"min\":50,\"prompt\":\"\",\"height\":\"\",\"width\":\"\",\"data_id\":\"\",\"more\":true,\"type\":\"\",\"autoshowmore\":false,\"link\":\"\",\"showdesc\":\"\",\"rankby\":\"\",\"ad_slots\":\"\",\"see-more-title\":\"\",\"searchdate\":\"\",\"searchenddate\":\"\",\"lat\":41.29790115356445,\"lng\":-74.45939636230469,\"latlng\":\"41.297901153564,-74.459396362305\",\"city\":\"Pine Island\",\"state\":\"NY\",\"theme\":\"\",\"page_type\":\"town\",\"grouped\":false,\"has_next_page\":true}","modified":"MongoDate(0.69200000 1766807305)","created":"MongoDate(0.69200000 1766807305)"} , true)	0	1
12	db.towns.find( {"sef_url":"pine-island-ny"}, [] ).sort( [] ).limit( 1 ).skip( 0 )	1	1
13	db.tokens.find( {"sef_url":{"$in":["usa","ny","orange-county-ny","pine-island-ny"]}}, [] ).sort( [] ).limit( 0 ).skip( 0 )	4	1
14	db.modules.find( {"name":"AT - Header Script"}, [] ).sort( [] ).limit( 1 ).skip( 0 )	1	1
15	db.modules.find( {"name":"AT - Header Section"}, [] ).sort( [] ).limit( 1 ).skip( 0 )	1	1
16	db.modules.find( {"name":"AT - Nearby Towns"}, [] ).sort( [] ).limit( 1 ).skip( 0 )	1	1
17	db.modules.find( {"name":"AT - Nav Bar"}, [] ).sort( [] ).limit( 1 ).skip( 0 )	1	1
18	db.modules.find( {"name":"CV Cancel"}, [] ).sort( [] ).limit( 1 ).skip( 0 )	1	1
19	db.modules.find( {"name":"AT - Footer Section"}, [] ).sort( [] ).limit( 1 ).skip( 0 )	1	1
20	db.modules.find( {"name":"AT - Footer Script"}, [] ).sort( [] ).limit( 1 ).skip( 0 )	1	1